 |
Prior, a one time fantasy icon is battling Wade Miller for the final spot in the rotation
|
For Worse
The following camp battles will get more attention than a Mike Tyson
return to the ring, but the fantasy implications are just as insignificant.
1. Chicago Cubs Fifth Starter (Mark Prior versus Wade Miller)
Flash
back to the early part of this decade when Prior was considered one of the best
pitchers in the game and a fantasy favorite. At the same time, Miller was
averaging 14 wins a season for Houston. With that said, this battle between two
players under 30 seems ridiculous. What truly is ridiculous is considering
either pitcher for your fantasy roster. Prior will have to hold off Miller this
spring if he wants a rotation spot in 2007. But if the truth be known, both
pitchers will likely be on the disabled list by May.
2. Minnesota Twins Fifth Starter (Matt Garza versus Scott Baker and Sidney
Ponson)
Twins fans will tell you that Garza is the frontrunner for the
fifth spot, but after leaving his Monday outing with a sore neck, the word on
the street is that he will begin the season on the farm. Baker has given up 13
hits in 3 1/3 innings this spring, so unfortunately for the Minnesota faithful,
it appears the thinner Ponson will begin the season as the fifth starter. Only
punch-drunk AL-only owners will get in the ring with the much-traveled
Ponson.
3. Oakland A's Outfield (Mark Kotsay versus Milton Bradley and Bobby
Kielty)
Kotsay was expected to be pampered this spring, creating a
complex platoon situation for the Athletics. But now that Kotsay will undergo
back surgery and is expected to be out 8-12 weeks, Bradley will start in center
and Kielty in right. Milton and Kielty are AL-only concerns, but due to the
patchwork necessary in the A's outfield, first baseman Dan Johnson is
primed for a better start to the '07 season. Unlike last year when Johnson
started the season 0-for-27, he need not look over his right shoulder into left
field because Oakland doesn't have the depth to send Nick Swisher back to
first base.
4. Philadelphia Phillies Catcher (Rod Barajas versus Carlos
Ruiz)
Finally, two names that truly sound like they could be a
lightweight bout on the under card of a headline act in Vegas. Barajas vs. Ruiz. In reality, this
is one of many positional battles that means little to fantasy managers. The
catcher position is deep in the National League and neither backstop will have
any real value on draft day outside of leagues that start two catchers. The
Philadelphia front office has already decided that the rookie Ruiz will be on
the active roster for Opening Day, but expect Charlie Manuel to go old school
and ease Ruiz into playing time and eventually a full-time platoon with
Barajas.
5. Los Angeles Dodgers Fifth Starter (Chad Billingsley versus Mark
Hendrickson, Brett Tomko and Hong-Chih Kuo)
The Dodgers rotation is set
one-through-four, and like most teams during spring training the battle for the
final spot will come down to March production. Billingsley was impressive on the
surface last year and is the favorite to begin the season as the final piece to
the rotation puzzle. Kuo and Tomko have scoreless March streaks going, making
both serious contenders to the favorite Billingsley. What does this mean for
fantasy owners? Nothing for those in the know. NL-only owners might gamble with
L.A.'s fifth starter in situational starts, but most will ignore the battle
completely.
Honorable Mention
Devil Rays Closer: Fantasy owners are offering Seth McClung too
much attention this offseason. Sure, he's a big hard throwing right-hander who
could offer saves in short-handed AL-only leagues, but his 1.83 WHIP and blown
saves are damaging regardless of the format. Dan Miceli and Shawn Camp will
vulture enough saves to make McClung irrelevant this season.
Devil Rays Fifth Starter: Considering the choices among Edwin
Jackson, J.P. Howell, Jason Hammel, Brian Stokes and
Jae Kuk Ryu, do even AL-only managers really care?
Royals Starting Rotation: The "K," a stadium that's been
hitter-friendly since making changes to the ballpark dimensions, has a cast and
crew of Zack Greinke, Brian Bannister, Todd Wellemeyer and
even Jorge De La Rosa fighting it out for the fourth and fifth rotation
spot. Yawn.
Remember, reactive approaches can only get you so far. Proactive approaches
are what will make you a legend. "It don't mean a thing if you don't win that
bling."