NL Positional Battles
Contributed By: Ray Flowers
As we enter the
final weeks of spring training the fantasy draft season starts to heat up. Who
will win that final roster spot? Will it be the rookie, the old man, or someone
unexpected? In this article I will review some of the Spring Training battles
in the National League. Some of the positions I will be discussing might
already be "settled" as far as the team goes, but even if that is the case,
there is still a good chance that those positions under discussion could see
some serious shifting at some point especially if the chosen starter were to
struggle in April.
***Spring
Training stats as of March 19th, 2007.
FIRST BASE: NATIONALS
Nick Johnson (.290-23-77-100-10 in 500 ABs)
Larry Broadway (.288-15-78-60-5 in 444 ABs)
Travis Lee (.224-11-31-35-50 in 343 ABs)
Dimitri Young (.250-7-23-19-1 in 172 ABs)
Robert Fick (.266-2-9-14-1 in 128 ABs)
This battlewould be a knockout if Johnson was healthy.
But as has become his M.O., that is not the case. Johnson's broken leg is
taking longer to heal than originally hoped, and now it looks like he might be
out until sometime in June, so only draft him late, and as a backup plan to
your starter at 1B. The team was expected to turn to the youngster Broadway, but
he was optioned to AAA on Sunday despite hitting .333 with a .391 OBP in spring
training. That seems to leave the 1B chores to either slick fielding Travis Lee
or the big stick of Young. Lee fell totally on his face last year with his
worst season (unfortunately he was on my AL Only roster as my DH), and while
Young faced his share of off-field issues last year, the man can still hit. So
even if Young doesn't start, he will likely garner a fair amount of ABs,
especially if Lee struggles (don't forget Young hit .271 with 21 HRs in 2005).
Robert Fick is also in the mix, but really, why?
SECOND BASE: PIRATES
Freddy Sanchez
(.344-6-85-85-3 in 582 ABs)
Jose Castillo (.253-14-65-65-4 in 518 ABs)
The team had hoped to play
NL batting champion Freddy Sanchez at just one spot this year (he played 99
games at 3B, 28 at SS and 23 at 2B last year), and they chose 2B top be his
home. However, he was injured on March 6th by a Rod Barajas takeout
slide, something he will have to work on dealing with if he stays at second
base. Sanchez knee has precluded him from playing in a spring training game
ever since, but he should be back on the field this week. Castillo was the
teams regular 2B last year and put up decent power numbers, though his OBP of
.299 was an unacceptably low number. Castillo has been accused of visiting
donut shops in the middle of the night, if you know what I mean, so the team
isn't sure he has the commitment necessary to be a long term answer. Add to
that the fact that he hit just .216 with 3 HRs in the second half last year,
and you can see why the Pirates want Sanchez to man the spot full time.
Castillo is still just 26 years-old and the teams current starting 3B is Jose
Batista who hit just .235 with 110 Ks in 400 ABs last season while playing
only 33 games at the hot corner (78 games in the OF). With Sanchez's
versatility, Castillo could easily see substantial time at 2B this year if
Sanchez is needed at 3B to cover for Batista.
THIRD BASE: DODGERS
Wilson Betemit
(.263-18-53-49-3 in 373 ABs)
Andy LaRoche
(.315-19-81-77-9 in 432 ABs at AA/AAA)
Wilson Betemit enters 2007
as the Dodgers starter at 3B, there is little question about that. The question
is, will Betemit be consistent enough to hold the position all year. Even
though he showed decent pop last season, Betemit struck out 102 times in less
than 400 ABs, and unless you have Adam Dunn power, that just isn't going
to get it done. LaRoche, the brother of Pirates 1B Adam, is one of the team's
top youngsters and the team would love to find a way to get his stick in the
lineup. Betemit is hitting only .229 this spring but LaRoche hasn't done any
better sporting a .216 mark. Look for LaRoche to start the year at AAA but be
the first guy the team will turn to if Betemit continues to struggle.
SHORTSTOP: ROCKIES
Troy Tulowitzki (.240-1-6-15-3 in 96 ABs)
Clint Barmes (.220-7-56-57-5 in 478 ABs)
Barmes just hasn't been the
same at the plate since he hurt his shoulder a year and a half ago. He has
seemingly lost his power, his average, and his contact rate has plummeted.
Barmes has also hit just .258 this spring, and there have been rumors he will
be sent to AAA as the team tries to trade him. Therefore, this isn't really a
competition to start the year since the team has basically announced that
Tulowitzki is the starter. The real question is will Troy be able to hold on to
the position and excel in his rookie year? Tulowitzki, the Rockies first-round
pick in the 2005 draft, hit .291-13-61-75-6 in 423 ABs at AA last year before a
late season call-up to the Rockies. Troy his hitting a robust .344 in the
spring but don't forget he has never had an AB at AAA and he has just 613 ABs
as a professional.
CATCHERS: PHILLIES
Rod Barajas
(.256-11-41-49-0 in 344 ABs in TEX)
Carlos Ruiz
(.261-3-10-5-0 in 69 ABs)
Chris Coste
(.328-7-32-25-0 in 198 ABs)
Rod Barajas left Texas to
sign a one-year deal to catch for the Phillies for roughly $2.5 million.
Barajas has recorded double digits in HRs three straight years and hit 21
longballs in 2005, the only season of his career in which re recorded 400 ABs.
Barajas is also a fine defensive C, so he will likely start the season as the
teams #1 option behind the dish considering he is also hitting .318 with 8 RBIs
this spring. However, the team is high on Ruiz, though his glove is somewhat
suspect. Over the past two season at AAA, Ruiz has hot .300 each year, and in
2006 he hit .307-16-69 in 368 ABs. The team could go with some sort of 65/35
split to start the season, especially since Barajas hit just .156 in 64 ABs
last year against southpaws. Coste is basically insurance for the other two,
though he might stick with the team as its last player on the bench. However,
he injured his hamstring earlier this week and that certainly won't help his
efforts to make the team. So much for hitting .328 last year huh?