Whether we’re talking about the Greeks and Romans, or a neighborhood
hair-pulling dustup between Shelbyville and Springfield after school,
it’s always been about defending your home turf. Same thing
goes in the NFL, where even if you’re more David than Goliath, it’s
always nice to sleep in your own bed and have 50,000 boisterous
hometown fans in your corner come Sunday. Sometimes that extra boost
gives you a puncher’s chance – or so the story goes.
Home-field
advantage is one of the game’s intangibles that oddsmakers try to put a
tangible value on every week. Obviously it’s far from an exact science
and will vary a bit depending on the stadium, but the general rule of
thumb makes home-field worth about a field goal on the posted
pointspread.
And I’ve been thumbing my nose at the idea that
home underdogs are generally more attractive than visiting pups
strictly because of the home-field factor for a while now.
But I needed backup so I put the statistical wizards of the office on Mythbusters
duty and found out home underdogs of 10 points or fewer have covered
50.6 percent of the time while road dogs of 10 or fewer points have
covered at 49.4 percent clip since the 1985 season.
So we’re
splitting hairs here over literally thousands of games. Makes you
wonder where this preconceived notion about the inherit value of home
underdogs comes from.
“A lot of it still stems from a historical
cycle more than a decade ago when home underdogs had a particularly
good run,” longtime professional handicapper David Malinsky says.
He doesn’t put nearly as much emphasis on home-field advantage as he used to either.
“With
modern travel being the way that it is even longer flights are not all
that difficult for teams any more,” Malinsky says. “And the funny thing
is that given the nature of the modern athlete, many times playing in
front of a hostile crowd can seem to fire players up even more than
when the crowd is behind them.”
Let’s hope that’s the case this week; the only underdogs I like are of the visiting variety. Coincidence? Never.
Miami at Buffalo – Dolphins +7
A
buddy of mine (pathetic, misguided Bills fan) was lucky enough to take
in the last meeting between these two teams in Miami from a great seat
right on the 50-yard line. Since then he hasn’t gone more than four
days without replaying a late Ted Ginn Jr. kickoff return that went the other way with a flag on the field.
If
you were at the game and saw a single dorky Canadian yelling “It’s
coming back! It’s coming back!” in a sea of Dolphins jubilation, you
have an idea about how annoying this can be.
Another defensive snoozefest this time around, minus the obnoxious Canuck. Take the points.
St. Louis at Cincinnati – Rams +6 ½
It
may not be saying much, but St. Louis is the best 3-9 team in the
league. What does say something, however, is that the Rams would have
won and covered their last four games if it weren’t for a fumbled snap
on the goal line two weeks ago against Seattle. Marc Bulger should be ready to go this week and he can go shot-for-shot with Cincinnati’s Carson Palmer with a healthy group of receivers.
It’s been a terrible year for the Rams but this team has some guts, something that can’t be said about the skittish Bengals.
Oakland at Green Bay – Raiders +10 ½
Brett Favre
should start, but his throwing elbow took a nasty whack last week so
Green Bay will be careful with him and backup Aaron Rogers is out with
a pulled hamstring. That means Craig Nall will make his sixth career appearance if the old gunslinger takes a seat.
That could be trouble against an Oakland team that’s all fired up over the JaMarcus Russell
era. The rookie looked great taking his first real NFL snaps last week
and while he probably won’t start, don’t be surprised if he gets in the
game at some point.
As much as I like the Packers, this looks like a tough spot for them. Plus, it looks like there’s a chance of snow at Lambeau.
Last week’s record: 2-1
Season record to date: 20-18-1