
When I look at Ohio State signal caller
Troy Smith, the first
word that comes to mind is leader. He has a presence about him in the huddle,
the pocket, and just about anywhere on the field. But another refreshing
observation about Smith is his maturity… he gets it. Smith understands his role
as a leader and what he has to do for his team, whether it’s on the field or
behind a microphone speaking to the media.
This brings to mind another quarterback, who is already in midst
of a stellar NFL career. Donovan McNabb is a quarterback that Smith idolized. I
think it’s safe to say that Smith has studied the way McNabb has handled
himself, on and off the field, and has taken a page from his book.
I’m not saying that Smith will become a player close to the
stature of McNabb, but potentially, Smith has all the intangibles to become a
dynamic player at the next level.
Many scouts and player personnel types will evaluate Smith on
film and critique his play: whether his throwing motion needs to improve; or if
he needs to stay in the pocket longer and locate his receiver; or if
genetically, he doesn’t have the size to succeed at the next level.
I say that’s a load of Buckeyes…
Are we really talking about height? Height is important to a
quarterback, especially if you have five gigantic heavyweights protecting you
upfront, but it isn’t all that important if you are mobile enough to escape the
pocket and become a playmaker on the run.
Smith is listed at 6-foot-1, 215-pounds, but we all know that is
probably embellished. Even if Smith’s real height is 6-foot, he’s still an
outstanding player for the number-one team in the country.
Smith won the Heisman Trophy. He led the Buckeyes to an
undefeated season and a National Championship victory over the Florida Gators.
Smith also managed to post 2,507 passing yards, 30 touchdowns and only five
interceptions in a very tough Big-10 Conference this season.
Those numbers alone should have NFL executives drooling at the
thought of adding Smith to their franchise. But the misconception of a
quarterback will always come down to a player’s size.
In the NFL at the moment, there are plenty of starting
quarterbacks listed at or under 6-foot-1. The assumption is that you need to be
the “prototypical” quarterback, which in the minds of many, is a strapping
6-foot-4, 220-pound quarterback with a rifle arm. Although a player of that
stature and ability is intriguing, he doesn’t always exist.
To be a successful quarterback in the NFL you need three main
qualities: intelligence, instincts, and the will to win. It sounds cliché, but
it’s true. Look at a player like Drew Brees. He’s not the biggest player or the
fastest, and he doesn’t have the strongest arm, but he knows how to win and lead
a team. The same can be said about McNabb.
McNabb led the Philadelphia Eagles to four-straight NFC
Championship Games, as well as a Super Bowl appearance. When his days at
Syracuse were over, many speculated that he was just an athlete playing
quarterback, and McNabb despised those accusations. Scouts knew the talent was
there, but questioned if his true potential would ever be realized.
The same can be said for Smith. Questions about his height and
ability to succeed at the next level will haunt his draft day status, but it
will be his leadership and intelligence that make him an exceptional pro.