
The NFL
combine has a way of changing the public perception of specific players. Many,
including life long organizational scouts, forget the good or the bad of an
individual player's career, instead, choosing to make judgment based solely on
a players combine performance. The Combine, a testing ground where players are
not required to participate in pads is overvalued and more often than not analyzed
without historical merit. It's almost as
if a players three or four years of college is good only for entry into the
week long February event, and that a players Combine numbers stands alone when
determining their worth.
Too much
value is placed on how fast, smart, or strong a player is at the Combine while
important questions such as leadership, character and football speed are practically
ignored. The event places far too much weight on the individuals physical
skills without the football. Tests like
the 40 yard dash, the Wonderlic, and bench press totals are over emphasized not
only by scouts, but by those in the media that cover the event. And while
these tests are never the ultimate measure of player's skill, sexy combine
numbers almost always influence a player's draft day slot.
This year
will be no different. The current consensus of the top-10 players on most website
Big Board will change. Those changes will occur based on the Combine numbers
they produce, not the individual's collegiate career.
The fact that quarterback Brady Quinn and JaMarcus Russell didn't work for scouts at the Combine was disappointing, but
not unexpected. Neither quarterback had much to gain by putting their top-ranked
status on the line this past weekend. The two will perform their Pro-Day in
comfortable surroundings without the pressure of 'who has done what' during the
week long Combine circus. Quinn and Russell's MIA status also provide specific
players and prospects, those who may have slipped into the proverbial crack, the
opportunity to shine and increase their draft day value.
Top wide
receiver prospect Calvin Johnson of Georgia Tech, who participated in but one
event, the 40-yard-dash, posted a blistering time of 4.35 seconds. Johnson was five-tenths of a second from the top of the speed chart at the Combine. Offensive tackle Joe Thomas of Ohio State,
defensive end Gaines Adams from Clemson, Oklahoma running back Adrian Peterson, and Michigan defensive
tackle Alan Branch all had productive Combines and are all an apparent lock as
top-10 selections in April's draft.
Also
making a statement this past weekend were Wolverine cornerback Leon Hall,
Louisiana State safety LaRon Landry, Penn
State offensive tackle Levi Brown, and
Louisville
defensive tackle Amobi Okoye. All have a very good chance of moving up
organizational draft charts with their Combine performances.
Those
players projected to be late first or early second-round selections that
damaged their value were players like Miami
linebacker Jon Beason who logged a mediocre 4.72 second forty-yard-dash. Also
disappointing in the Combine speed test were Arizona
State tight end Zach Miller's (4.89)
Bulldog defensive end Quentin Moses (4.85), and South Carolina wide out Sidney Rice (4.55). Considering
the fact that Pro scouts take a long hard look at speed, especially at the
position of outside linebacker, defensive end and wide receiver, the trio
likely lost draft value which translates into a decrease in signing dollars.
On the flip
side, players like Arkansas cornerback Chris
Houston (4.32), wide receiver Robert Meachem (4.39) of Tennessee,
and defensive back Brandon Meriweather (4.47) of Miami, all helped their stock and made a
significant move up the Big Board with their blazing performances in "The Dash"
for cash.
No one
gets a second chance to make a first impression, but the upcoming Pro Days
offer the opportunity of redemption for those in need. A good or bad
performance during a job interview doesn't define the employee, a career does
that. Leaving many to question; is too much value placed on an individual's
performance at the NFL Combine?
